A tight 1.17-inch three-shot cluster at 50 yards proved the carbine and ammo combination could be counted on. An AR-15 in 9mm or.300 Blackout, with subsonic ammunition, for example, is markedly quieter than the same-size carbine chambered in.223 Rem./5.56 NATO. The MP5 is whisper quiet. I continue to be baffled by the notion that if a gun doesn't leave the owner … SHTF scenario the 3 most common calibers available will be 5.56, 9mm, and 7.62x51/.308. I imagine the AR is quite a bit louder. To set the stage, nearly identical platforms from SIG Sauer were chosen: a 9mm MPX and an MCX Virtus in .300 Blackout, both suppressed. Similar velocity to.22LR but 130grain vs 40. I built the 9mm one just to use with my 9mm suppressor, and because it's fun. I have a 7" barreled 9mm AR-15, and a 14.5" barreled 5.56 AR-15. I just don't see the logic in having a pistol caliber in a rifle size gun even a carbine. While the 147gr Federal HST expanded from 9mm (roughly .35cal) to on average 15mm or .61″, the .45 ACP expanded from (again, roughly) 11.5mm to 25mm (.45″ to 1″) Both (roughly!) ks123 said: So as the title suggests, I'm torn between buying an ar-15 or a 9mm PCC. You're looking at about 1300 fps vs 2700 fps or so in the 223. Add to Cart ; 16" 9MM Straight Profile AR 15 Barrel, Modern Series 0 Review . Benching the rifle, once I had the EOTech optic properly zeroed, I put some test patterns downrange. - YouTube J. The difference in the recoil of the 5.7 and the 9mm is pretty much noticeable. Final Thoughts. This segment of “Cameras Don’t Lie” is a subsonic showdown, 9mm vs. .300 Blackout. A good off gun flashlight and laser on your G17 is probably as good a home defense weapon as any. The standard safe distance from steel targets with 9mm is generally accepted at 10 yards. The 9mm cartridge also delivers less felt recoil than similar calibers, While a .22 LR has a felt recoil measured in ounces, a 124 grain 9mm round generates around 4.5 lbs of felt recoil while the larger 160 grain .40 S&W generates 50% more felt recoil – coming in at 6.3 lbs on average. By definition, a rifle must have at least a 16-inch barrel. It seems intuitive that it’s easier to shoot accurately with a carbine or rifle than a pistol … This is a win for the 5.7x28mm. Drywall Penetration: 9mm vs. 223 vs. 22 LR Russ Chastain 10.09.18 As you are probably aware, wall penetration is a common topic discussed by those who debate which round is … 5.7x28mm VS 9mm Magazine Capacity. Accuracy on both is better than me and better than a 9mm has any right to be. 9x19mm For the 9mm pistol ammunition side, the new Winchester PDX1 brand was tested. Mar 19, 2008 56,567 113 Kerr County. Benching the rifle, once I had the EOTech optic properly zeroed, I put some test patterns downrange. The resulting groups were predictably tight. The 9mm won't magically start punching through body armor because you juiced it up. Out of Stock. They're also very powerful in comparison to a lot of other options, and very easy to shoot. I looked into both for a long time as I was deciding on my SBR, and the 223 just had too much going for it, … The AR-15 is the most popular rifle in America, and it should be easy to find ammunition and parts while scavenging. One benefit of the standard AR-15 platform is the use of an adjustable stock. That’s loud enough to cause permanent hearing damage and physical pain. There are AR-15's chambered in 9mm. I haven't seen that in the 9mm but it doesn't cause the 9mm bullet to suddenly become a 2000 fps projectile. Even though this lower receiver looks different than the AR-15's lower, it uses the same parts kit, trigger, hammer, safety, and other components that aren't preinstalled. 60 grain bullet going 2.5 times as fast. Ease of Aim. $105.00. The 9mm AR15 Trigger is easily where the most confusion lies with the 9mm AR platform. TGT Supporter. Affiliation: Mad Dawg Global Marketing, Inc. That's why they kill people so effectively. As for the .45 Automatic pistol vs carbine ballistic test can be found […] American Tactical Mil-Sport, 9mm Luger AR carbine. 9mm is often the perfect caliber for shooters to move up once they are comfortable with the 22 LR. 22 LR is often a much cheaper option as compare to 9mm ammo. Add to that about eight inches for the receiver, so no matter what you do with the stock, you’re looking at 24 inches of minimum overall length. Consider, for example, that from a 10.5″ SBR barrel, 5.56mm offers twice the muzzle energy and essentially twice range (by trajectory) than the 9mm when fired from rifle barrels; the common 16″ civilian carbine produces nearly three times the energy of the 9mm. The 9mm can be used in rifle form for training and is still a blast to shoot. Just because you put a pistol round into a rifle doesn't mean that it will perform like a rifle round. 5.7x28mm VS 9mm Soft Body Armor Penetration A pistol caliber carbine like a 9mm AR-15 isn’t for everyone. The magazine… Low Levels of Felt Recoil. An AR15 shooting 5.56 is a different thing. This is a great choice of 9mm carbine to make for its superior reliability and maximum accuracy. Basically, 9mm gives you stopping power. The die has long since been cast and the Stoner-based carbine is now the patrol rifle of choice for U.S. law enforcement. AR9 or AR15 pistol - which is better for defense? You're better off with a 9mm pistol with a high capacity magazine. Blowback vs. Gas. Sound is measured in decibels (Db) on a logarithmic scale. California Compliant: Kriss Vector Gen II CRB. If yours doesn’t have one, it’s simple and inexpensive to add. For example, the Ruger 57’s standard magazine holds 20 rounds. For these reasons, the AR-15 is the ideal SHTF firearm. When it comes to magazine capacity comparing standard length magazines the 5.7x28mm has the advantage due to its smaller case diameter. It is a successful conversion of the AR-15; therefore it has maintained much of the handling and controls of the AR platform.That is why you can count on it for its effectiveness in home defense.. The AR is quite comfortable but will never be quite as good as my MP5. The 5.7 allows you to put rounds down range more accurately than the 9mm due to its low recoil. 9x19mm. A 9MM pistol, a PCC, an AR15, shotgun, doesn't matter. Compare the damage an AR-15 and a 9mm handgun can do to the human body: “One looks like a grenade went off in there,” says Peter Rhee, a trauma surgeon at the University of Arizona. That is a world of difference and the close range fits much more into what I am looking for when it comes to training and recreation. For the 9mm pistol ammunition side, the new Winchester PDX1 brand was tested. The best idea is to keep a set of electronic ear muffs with your HD firearm, and hope you remember to use them. Keep em both. $135.00. Maybe some 7.62x39 What you need for small game hunting is a pellet gun and a .22 rifle with a suppressor. Yes, an AR15 penetrates less than most other HD options, which is a great thing. My own research was met with a lot of “Should work”, “Most 2-Stage” and similar vague answers. If you look at both the pros and the cons, you will find … Mike Detty. $155.00. Unsuppressed, reliability I'd say is about equal. I have a Glock G26 with a 50 round drum and a G30 w/27 round stick mag. .380 Auto pistol vs carbine - Range Hot - March 3, 2016 […] you are curious how the .380 carbine stacks up against the 9mm Luger carbine, follow this link to see that ballistic test. Most collapsible stocks are about 7 ½ inches long when fully collaps… - Range Hot - April 11, 2016 Terminal ballistics of a rifle round are almost always superior to that of a pistol round, simply as a function of velocity. The easy shooting 22 LR is excellent for new shooters and older people. Firing the 5.7 from a Ruger-57 produces 35 percent less recoil than the 9mm fired from a Glock19. Home; Tactical; Firearm Accessories; Carbine Training: 9mm vs. .223 Rem. May 21, 2016 #3 Charlie TGT Addict. That said, a pistol caliber carbine (PCC) does have some very specific advantages in a home-defense scenario. A tight 1.17-inch three-shot cluster at 50 yards proved the carbine and ammo combination could be counted on. As an example of how loud a gunshot can be, a .22 caliber rifle with standard velocity ammo creates 140 dB of sound. More powerful centerfire ammo is even louder. 11" 9MM AR 15 Barrel, Modern Series 0 Review . I can carry the guns on my hip with their standard magazines and keep the high capacity ones loaded and accessible. The 3S1 Scorpion Carbine from CZ USA is today considered to be one of the best 9mm carbines on the market. The resulting groups were predictably tight. doubled in size…and since .45 ACP is bigger to start with, it became massive in the end. While all rifles don’t have that feature, you can consider it “standard” as most come with that configuration. 2 Wilson Combat- AR 9 Carbine 9mm 16’’ Beretta Mag. The new ejector is required because the 9mm cartridge doesn't use a gas system like the typical AR-15. The 9mm burns most of its powder inside the breech. One of the problems is most AR15 TRIGGER manufacturers have not tested their triggers in 9mm AR15 rifles. Add to Cart ; 5.5" 9MM AR 15 Barrel, Modern Series (1/2x36 Threads) 0 Review .